In a resolution adopted Wednesday, three chambers of the Supreme Court (SN) ruled that a ruling of the Constitutional Tribunal (TK) is a decision issued by a panel composed solely of people who, after being elected by the Sejm, Poland’s lower house of parliament, took an oath in the presence of the president.
– A Constitutional Tribunal ruling has universally binding force regardless of whether it has been published in an official gazette, the resolution also states.
Justice Aleksander Stępkowski said in presenting the reasoning for the resolution: “Because of the extraordinary circumstances in which the institutions of the justice system have had to operate, the Supreme Court, in the combined-chamber panel present here, found it appropriate to comprehensively address the issue of the universally binding force of Constitutional Tribunal rulings.”
Justice Stępkowski specified that Constitutional Tribunal rulings may be issued by panels composed solely of people who, among other things, took the oath in the president’s presence at that ceremony. – In extraordinary situations, one can imagine that this would be presence remotely, through available means of communication – he added.
The resolution was adopted Wednesday afternoon, after a full day of proceedings, by three combined Supreme Court chambers: the Civil Chamber; the Labor and Social Insurance Chamber; and the Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs. In all, more than 40 judges took part, the vast majority of them appointed to the Supreme Court through procedures before the National Council of the Judiciary (KRS) after 2017.
The resolution was adopted in response to questions from Joanna Misztal-Konecka, president of the Supreme Court’s Civil Chamber. Her motion contained three questions in total. They concerned, among other things, the force of Constitutional Tribunal rulings that have not been published in the past two years.
Marcin Jabłoński (PAP)