PSL After Belweder Meeting: We Have Begun a Long Road to Calm the Situation Around the Constitutional Tribunal
Magdalena Sroka, deputy head of the Polish People’s Party (PSL) parliamentary club, said after Monday’s meeting at Belweder on the Constitutional Tribunal that, in her view, it marks the beginning of a long road toward calming and repairing the situation.
On Monday, Zbigniew Bogucki, head of the Chancellery of the President, met at Belweder with representatives of political groups on the effort to heal the situation in the Constitutional Tribunal (TK). Representatives of the Left, the Civic Coalition and Centrum did not attend. Politicians from the Polish People’s Party, Poland 2050, Razem, Confederation, Confederation of the Polish Crown, Law and Justice, Rozwój Plus and the Senate caucus Nowa Polska-Centrum were present.
PSL club head Krzysztof Paszyk told reporters after the meeting that it was “not easy.” “But it was hard to expect that we would immediately resolve all the challenges on the road to healing the Constitutional Tribunal,” he said.
He stressed that PSL was the only club to come “with a very concrete proposal to amend the constitution.” “It was the proposal that participants referred to most often, including the host of the meeting, Minister Bogucki,” Paszyk said, adding that in PSL’s view “these solutions are worth every effort.”
“In all the polls (…) Poles want calm. A constitutional amendment, (…) a law renewing the Constitutional Tribunal, is the solution that today appears to be the only one (to) solve this problem,” he argued.
Magdalena Sroka, for her part, said that it was stated several times during Monday’s meeting that the PSL draft is “the leading one, the most far-reaching, and is a concrete proposal on which we will continue to work.” “The next step is already on Thursday, a public hearing in the Sejm; other parties have already declared that they will take part,” she said, stressing that “the voice from the Presidential Palace was also favorable, referring to this hearing as a party that will participate.”
“I think we have begun a long road to calm this situation (around the TK) and repair it, so that in the future the Constitutional Tribunal is not a political prize and does not pass from hand to hand,” said the deputy head of the PSL club.
The constitutional amendment proposed by PSL would add a provision under which the National Assembly (the Sejm and Senate sitting jointly, 560 lawmakers in total) “may, at the reasoned request of the National Council of the Judiciary, declare the permanent inability of the Constitutional Tribunal to perform its duties.”
This would require a resolution of the National Assembly adopted by a majority of at least 3/5 of its statutory number of members, that is, the votes of at least 336 lawmakers. Under the PSL proposal, after such a resolution was adopted, the National Assembly would elect 15 TK judges in a single vote, by the same majority – five each for terms of 3, 6 and 9 years.
The motion containing the nominations for TK judges, chosen from among people “distinguished by legal knowledge,” would be submitted by the Sejm speaker after consulting, among others, the first presidents of the Supreme Court and the Supreme Administrative Court, and after obtaining the prior consent of the president of Poland.
Amending the constitution is difficult because it requires a majority of at least 2/3 of the votes in the Sejm and an absolute majority in the Senate. The president, the Senate or at least 1/5 of the statutory number of Sejm deputies may initiate an amendment to the constitution. The Senate has 60 days to consider an amendment passed by the Sejm and cannot introduce changes to it.
On Oct. 30, representatives of the group elected as TK judges during the current term of the Sejm announced that Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, as the longest-serving judge, had become the acting head of the Constitutional Tribunal and had issued an order placing TK President Bogdan Święczkowski and Vice President Bartłomiej Sochański on a break from their duties.
Święczkowski called this a usurpation. President Karol Nawrocki also stated at the time, among other things, that “the constitutional order of the Republic of Poland had been violated and a constitutional organ of the state had been taken over by force.”
Prime Minister Donald Tusk, in turn, stated, among other things, that the current Sejm had elected new TK judges, but the president had not accepted the oath from some of them, Święczkowski had prevented them from starting work, and when after many weeks of waiting they decided to take up their duties, they “were attacked.”
On Thursday, the prime minister stressed that “the matter is settled as far as the TK is concerned.” “Settled in the sense that we have a Tribunal, and it will issue rulings, I hope. Very many citizens are waiting for rulings and interpretations from the TK,” he noted. (PAP)